A-Level Economics October/November 2024 Q2(a): Explain the determinants of supply for an agricultural product, such as rice, and consi…

1 answer

• ▲0
  accepted ✓

  Supply refers to the quantity of a good or service that producers are willing and able to offer for sale at various prices over a given period. The supply of an agricultural product like rice is influenced by several unique determinants.

  Determinants of Supply (AO1)

  Several factors determine the supply of rice. Firstly, physical and climatic factors are crucial. Rice cultivation requires specific conditions, including substantial water, high temperatures, and suitable soil. Favourable weather, such as an optimal monsoon season in South Asia, will increase the yield per hectare and shift the supply curve for rice to the right. Conversely, droughts, floods, or unseasonal temperatures can devastate crops, reducing the harvest and shifting the supply curve to the left.

  Secondly, the cost of production significantly impacts supply. This includes the price of inputs like seeds, fertilisers, pesticides, labour, and fuel for machinery. A decrease in the price of fertiliser, for example, would lower production costs, making rice farming more profitable at any given price. This would incentivise farmers to increase production, shifting the supply curve to the right.

  Thirdly, technology and infrastructure play a vital role. The development and adoption of high-yield variety (HYV) seeds, advanced irrigation systems, and mechanised farming techniques (like tractors and harvesters) can dramatically increase productivity and thus supply. Similarly, the availability of good storage facilities allows producers to store their harvest and sell it later, which can help to smooth supply throughout the year and reduce wastage.

  Finally, the prices of other agricultural products (substitutes in production) are a key determinant. A farmer's land is a finite resource. If the price of an alternative crop, such as wheat or maize, rises significantly relative to the price of rice, a farmer may be incentivised to switch from cultivating rice to the more profitable crop. This would decrease the amount of land dedicated to rice, shifting the supply curve for rice to the left.

  Analysis of Importance (AO2)

  The impact of these determinants can be analysed through shifts in the supply curve. For instance, a government subsidy on fertiliser (reducing costs) or the introduction of a new drought-resistant rice strain (a technological improvement) would both lead to an increase in supply, represented by a rightward shift of the supply curve. This means that at any given price, a greater quantity of rice would be supplied. In contrast, an increase in the minimum wage for agricultural labour or a poor monsoon season would increase costs or reduce yields, causing a decrease in supply and a leftward shift of the curve. The ability to store rice, which is non-perishable when kept dry, means that supply can be more responsive to price changes in the medium term compared to highly perishable goods, as producers can release stocks when prices are high. However, in the short run, supply is highly inelastic as it is constrained by the fixed growing season and harvest time.

  Evaluation of Significance (AO3)

  While all these factors are important, climate change is arguably the determinant of greatest significance for the supply of rice at the present time. Climate change is exacerbating the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events, such as the severe floods in Pakistan or the heatwaves in India, both major rice-producing regions. These events are no longer rare shocks but are becoming a chronic and unpredictable constraint on production. This directly impacts yields in a way that is difficult and expensive for individual farmers or even governments to mitigate in the short term.

  Other factors, while significant, are arguably secondary to this overarching environmental challenge. For example, while a change in the price of wheat might cause some farmers to switch crops, the fundamental ability to grow any crop is threatened by climate-related disasters like prolonged drought or soil salinisation from rising sea levels. Technological advances may offer solutions, but their development and widespread adoption take time and significant investment, and they are often in a race against the worsening climate. Therefore, due to its global scale, increasing intensity, and direct impact on the fundamental viability of cultivation, climate change is the most significant determinant currently affecting the global supply of rice.

  ---

  How the marks are awarded

  • M1 — Awarded for knowledge and understanding of physical factors as a determinant of supply. The answer explains the role of 'physical and climatic factors' like weather, water, and soil on rice yields.
  • M1 — Awarded for knowledge and understanding of infrastructural factors. The answer identifies 'technology and infrastructure' including irrigation systems and storage facilities as a key determinant.
  • M1 — Awarded for knowledge and understanding of the prices of other agricultural products. The answer explains how the price of 'substitutes in production' like wheat can affect a farmer's decision to grow rice.
  • M3 — Awarded for analysis of the importance of determinants. The answer explains how factors cause a shift in the supply curve ('a rightward shift' or 'a leftward shift') and links this to the quantity supplied at a given price. (1/3)
  • M3 — Awarded for further analysis. The answer develops the analysis by contrasting the impact of positive factors (subsidies, technology) with negative factors (wage increases, poor weather). (2/3)
  • M3 — Awarded for developed analysis. The answer correctly identifies that supply is inelastic in the short run due to the growing season but that storage makes it more elastic in the medium term. (3/3)
  • M1 — Awarded for offering a valid judgement on the most significant determinant. The answer identifies 'climate change' as the most significant factor 'at the present time' and provides initial justification.
  • M1 — Awarded for reaching a supported conclusion. The answer justifies the choice of climate change over other factors, explaining why its impact is more fundamental and widespread, thus forming a complete evaluation.

  Common mistakes

  • Confusing supply with quantity supplied, for example, stating that 'an increase in the price of rice increases supply' instead of correctly identifying this as an increase in quantity supplied (a movement along the curve).
  • Listing determinants like 'weather' or 'technology' without explaining the mechanism through which they affect supply (e.g., how good weather increases yield and shifts the supply curve right).
  • Making a weak or unjustified evaluation, such as stating 'weather is the most important' without linking it to a contemporary issue like climate change or explaining why it is more significant than other factors like costs.
  • Providing a generic answer about supply that could apply to any product, failing to use the specific context of an 'agricultural product' like rice, which involves unique factors like growing seasons, climate dependency, and perishability/storage.

  Examiner tip: For 'explain and consider' questions, use the 'Point, Explain, Evaluate' structure: state a determinant, explain its mechanism on the supply curve, and then evaluate its relative importance against others to answer all parts of the question.

  ---

  AI-generated model answer, grounded in the official Cambridge mark scheme and reviewed by the MarkScheme team. Mark your own answer to this question →

  @markscheme_answers

Your answer

Sign in to answer this question.