Skip to content

9084 · 1.1.5

Judicial precedent

9084 — stare decisis, hierarchy of courts, ratio/obiter, and avoiding precedent.

Need to know

What you need to know

  • Stare decisis is the foundational principle of judicial precedent, promoting legal certainty and fairness.
  • Precedent operates through a strict hierarchy: Supreme Court > Court of Appeal > High Court > Lower Courts.
  • A 'binding precedent' is a decision from a higher or equivalent court that must be followed.
  • A 'persuasive precedent' is not binding but can influence a judge's decision (e.g., a decision from a lower court, or the JCPC).

Explanation

Judicial precedent

  1. Stare decisis is the foundational principle of judicial precedent, promoting legal certainty and fairness.
  2. Precedent operates through a strict hierarchy: Supreme Court > Court of Appeal > High Court > Lower Courts.
  3. A 'binding precedent' is a decision from a higher or equivalent court that must be followed.
  4. A 'persuasive precedent' is not binding but can influence a judge's decision (e.g., a decision from a lower court, or the JCPC).