Step 1: Classify the strategies using Ansoff's Matrix.
- Option 1 is Market Development: selling an existing product (spray) in a new market (neighbouring country).
- Option 2 is Product Development: selling a new product (detergent) in an existing market (home country).
Step 2: Calculate the expected profit for Option 1 (Market Development).
- Contribution per unit = Price - Variable Cost = 5.00−2.00 = 3.00
- Total Contribution = Contribution per unit × Forecast Sales = $3.00 × 100,000 units = $300,000
- Expected Profit = Total Contribution - Initial Investment = 300,000−200,000 = **100,000∗∗
Step 3: Calculate the expected profit for Option 2 (Product Development).
- Contribution per unit = Price - Variable Cost = 8.00−3.00 = 5.00
- Total Contribution = Contribution per unit × Forecast Sales = $5.00 × 80,000 units = $400,000
- Expected Profit = Total Contribution - Initial Investment = 400,000−300,000 = **100,000∗∗
Step 4: Recommendation and Justification.
Both options are forecast to generate the same first-year profit of $100,000. Therefore, the decision must be based on risk and strategic fit.
- Market Development (Option 1) carries risks associated with entering a new country: cultural differences, new competitors, and different legal regulations. However, the product is proven.
- Product Development (Option 2) carries risks associated with R&D and product acceptance. Will the new detergent be effective? Will existing customers trust the EcoClean brand for laundry? However, the market and distribution channels are well understood.
Recommendation: If EcoClean has strong R&D capabilities and brand loyalty, Option 2 (Product Development) may be preferable as it builds on existing customer relationships and avoids the complexities of international expansion. If the company's strength is in marketing and logistics, Option 1 could be chosen. The 'best' choice depends on the company's core competencies and risk appetite.